Homes for Sale/Colorado County/Eagle Lake/Eagle Lake
Active MLS #51518703 · 55 days on market

501 McCarty Avenue

Eagle Lake, TX 77434
Subdivision  ·  Eagle Lake
List Price
$675,000
$146/SF · 53.7% above neighborhood median
Beds
4
Baths
4
Sq Ft
4,614
Built
1900
Lot
0.78 ac
Garage
3-car
County
Colorado
Tax Rate
2.10%

Schools

§ 03
District
Elementary EAGLE LAKE INT B
Middle RICE JH F
High RICE H S B
TEA accountability ratings reflect 2024–25 where available. School attendance zones are subject to district redistricting — confirm directly with the district before making a school-based decision.

Overview

§ 01

Statuesque, preserved, + a keeper of a century’s worth of stories is 501 N. McCarty in Eagle Lake. An idyllic setting among the oak-lined street, within walking distance to Town Square, this once-in-a-lifetime home asks you to consider its next chapter. Designed by the notable A.E. Barnes, this picturesque residence beckons. The expansive front porch with Haint blue ceiling, the detailed interiors with abundant stained glass, the horse-hair stucco walls, ornate mouldings and ceiling treatments meet as an unapologetic formality of a bygone era that will captivate you. The First floor offers a wealth of living and entertaining spaces, while the Second floor’s 4 bedrooms + 3 bathrooms, along with a sizeable Game Room, offers respite. Other notable features include: a full Basement, Elevator, 3-car garage with 2nd-floor quarters, full Attic, + tennis court on a large, lushly landscaped lot. Come celebrate Eagle Lake’s past and be part of her future in this truly standout estate.

Features

§ 02

Interior

  • All Bedrooms Up
  • Crown Molding
  • Entrance Foyer
  • Elevator
  • En Suite Bathroom
  • Handicap Access
  • Hollywood Bath
  • High Ceilings
  • Kitchen Island
  • Multiple Staircases
  • Pots And Pan Drawers
  • Pantry
  • Sitting Area In Primary
  • Separate Shower
  • Tub Shower
  • Upper Level Primary
  • Vanity
  • Walk In Closets

Exterior & lot

  • Covered Patio
  • Deck
  • Sprinkler Irrigation
  • Paved Driveway
  • Patio
  • Private Yard
  • Tennis Courts
  • Subdivision
  • None
  • Covered
  • Roof: Other
  • Foundation: Pillar Post Pier
  • Additional Parking
  • Detached
  • Garage

Community

  • Style: Craftsman
  • Style: English
  • Style: Traditional
  • Style: Victorian
  • Style: Historic Antique

Property Details

§ 03 · Full MLS record

Property

Property Type Residential
Architectural Style Craftsman, English, Traditional, Victorian, Historic Antique
Year Built 1900
Year Built Source PublicRecords
New Construction No

Building

Stories 2
Levels Two
Living Area 4,614 sq ft
Living Area Source Appraiser
Building Area Total 4,614 sq ft
Foundation Pillar Post Pier
Construction Brick, Vinyl Siding
Roof Other
Accessibility Accessible Elevator Installed

Rooms & Baths

Bedrooms 4
Bedrooms Possible 4
Bathrooms (total) 4
Bathrooms Full 3
Bathrooms Half 1
Rooms Total 17
Fireplaces 3
Fireplace Features Decorative, Wood Burning

Interior

Interior Features All Bedrooms Up, Crown Molding, Entrance Foyer, Elevator, En Suite Bathroom, Handicap Access, Hollywood Bath, High Ceilings, Kitchen Island, Multiple Staircases, Pots And Pan Drawers, Pantry, Sitting Area In Primary, Separate Shower, Tub Shower, Upper Level Primary, Vanity, Walk In Closets, Window Treatments
Flooring Carpet, Tile, Wood
Appliances Double Oven, Dishwasher, Disposal, Gas Oven, Gas Range, Microwave
Laundry Washer Hookup, Electric Dryer Hookup
Windows Window Coverings

Exterior

Exterior Features Covered Patio, Deck, Sprinkler Irrigation, Paved Driveway, Patio, Private Yard, Tennis Courts
Patio / Porch Covered, Deck, Patio
Fencing None
Pool Private No

Parking & Garage

Garage Spaces 3
Attached Garage No
Parking Features Additional Parking, Detached, Garage

Lot

Lot Size (acres) 0.7757
Lot Size Source Appraiser
Lot Features Subdivision
Direction Faces South

Location

County Colorado
MLS Area Major 56
Subdivision Eagle Lake
Road Surface Concrete
Postal Code 77434

Utilities

Heating Central, Gas, Zoned
Cooling Central Air, Electric, Zoned
Water Source Public
Sewer Public Sewer
Energy Efficient Exposure Shade

Taxes, Terms & Disclosures

Tax Annual Amount $14,144
Tax Year 2025
Tax Rate (est.) 2.10%
Parcel # 13076
Legal Description BLK 42 LT 1,2B EAGLE LAKE HOUSE, GARAGE & TENNIS COURT
Listing Terms Cash, Conventional
Lease Considered No
Disclosures None

Room Layout

§ 04 · 17 rooms · MLS-supplied

Main level · 10

Sunroom 22x18
Bonus Room 11x5
Den 27x14
Pantry 8x6
Entry Foyer 26x9
Kitchen 14x13
Living Room 17x14
Breakfast Room Nook 13x9
Dining Room 23x12
Utility Room 12x6

Second level · 5

Primary Bedroom 20x19
Bedroom 16x13
Bedroom 14x16
Bedroom 15x15
Game Room 24x18

Other · 2

Basement 15x11
Garage Apartment 20x19

MUD Disclosure (§49.452)

§ 03 · Data moat
● §49.452 Notice
Not in archive
This MUD is not yet in our §49.452 archive. We'll add it on request.

Texas Water Code §49.452 requires districts to publish annual notices with tax rate, bonded indebtedness, and assessed value. Most Harris-area MUDs publish these; a handful managed by Inframark do not.

Request this notice
● What this tells you

The §49.452 notice is the only public document that lists a MUD's exact tax rate, outstanding bond debt, and the assessed value used to compute your taxes — direct from the district, not the MLS. If the district is newer or has more bonds outstanding than its neighbors, your effective tax rate will be higher here than just across the street.

Listing's rolled-up MUD rate Resolved MUD jurisdiction not mapped Match confidence

Taxes & Cost of Ownership

§ 04
Tax breakdown not availableWe could not resolve the taxing jurisdictions for this listing. We will enrich this when the county tax roll loads.

HOA & Community

§ 05
No HOA on recordIf this is an HOA property, details are not yet loaded. Full cert available on request.

Broadband & Connectivity

§ 06
Broadband not mappedWe have not yet resolved FCC provider data for this block.

Environmental Risk

§ 08
?
FEMA Zone
Flood zone: not mapped by FEMA for this area
No FEMA digital flood map covers this location, so this property's flood risk has not been established. Verify flood insurance requirements with your lender.
SFHA NOT DETERMINED
🌡 Heat days >95°F
72 days/yr above 95°F
Plus 24 days above 100°F. NOAA station records, 2016-2025 average.
🌵 Drought (current)
D1 · Moderate
US Drought Monitor county reading, week of 2026-09-15.
Sources: FEMA NFHL · NOAA GHCN-Daily · EPA AQS · US Drought Monitor. Climate rollup last computed Sep 23, 2026.

Recent Comparable Sales

§ 09
6 comparable sales nearby · sold median $95/SFAddress-level sold detail is available to registered users. Reach out to Allen for the full comparable-sales report.

Subdivision & Master Plan

§ 10
● Master plan
Eagle Lake
TIER: SUBDIVISION
Subdivision name (MLS)Eagle Lake City · ZIPEagle Lake · 77434 CountyColorado Listings in subdivision245 Active now13 Sold (last 12 mo)11 Curated amenities0
● Year-built distribution
1950s 1 1960s 1 1970s 1 2025s 1

Fire Protection

§ 11
Nearest station
Eagle Lake Volunteer Fire Department
Distance
0.2 mi
Straight-line from listing
ISO rating
Future data point
Avg. response
From incident log (future)

Neighborhood Demographics

§ 12 · Census tract 48089750100 · ACS 2023
Median HH income
$71,709
ACS 2023
Median home value
$108,200
Census self-report
Owner-occupied
70%
1,871 housing units
Bachelor's+
21%
Adults 25+
Median age
38.7
Population 4,375
Work from home
8%
of commuters
Commute 45min+
26%
of commuters
Below poverty
10.5%
tract-level

Amenities & Nearby Places

§ 13

Active listing — amenities should populate from the go-live pipeline. Click to fetch now if missing.

Location & Neighborhood

§ 13
● This Home
501 N McCarty Avenue, Eagle Lake, TX 77434
Colorado County · 29.59°N, 96.33°W
No curated amenities within 2 mi yet.
Interactive map coming in v0.2 — currently showing schematic placement.
● Listing History
Jul 31, 2026 Listed $675,000 Brian Spack
Dec 31, 1899 Built
Status change events from HAR MLS (future: full audit trail)
● Disclosures & Attribution
Listed by Brian Spack · Martha Turner Sotheby's International Realty
Data provided by Houston Realtors Information Service (HAR MLS). Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All measurements, square footage, and school assignments should be independently verified. HAR MLS content last updated Sep 14, 2026.
MLS# 51518703 · LIST DATE: Jul 31, 2026 · PARCEL: 13076
R
EHO
REALTOR® · Equal Housing Opportunity
HAR.com Copyright © 2026, Houston Realtors Information Service, Inc. Deemed reliable, not guaranteed — independently verify. HARMLS last updated Sep 23, 2026, 11:00 PM CDT. Properties may subsequently be sold or off-market. Equal Housing Opportunity